"How important is it that my trainer look like he/she is in shape?"
As a twenty year veteran of the fitness world it's a question I've heard asked on more than one occasion by fitness professionals and potential clients alike.
Well, in a world where (for better or worse) Jillian Michaels is the most famous personal trainer on the planet and where most of our clients come to use wanting to improve their appearance -- I'd say it's pretty important.
That said, maybe ten years ago (6 certifications and masters degree in exercise physiology in hand) I think I might have argued to the contrary, that knowledge is everything and there are plenty of idiots who look good but really don't know what they are doing.
The thing is, the two aren't mutually exclusive. There is no reason that fitness professionals shouldn't have BOTH -- brains AND an appearance that might suggest they actually use some of this stuff.
Now, certainly I'm not saying everyone has to have a "perfect body" (whatever that is). But I do think that anyone who wants a career getting other people in shape should look like they use "the product" themselves.
It's a little like going to a fat cardiologist who's smoking and eating a cheeseburger during your consultation. It would be a little hard to take his advice (however well-informed) seriously. It's the proverbial "physician heal thyself".
Nobody underscored this fact more to me then Martin Rooney, famed strength and conditioning expert (who also happens to be shredded like a head of lettuce).
Several years ago, I sat in on one of his lectures as he called out an entire room full of personal trainers and strength coaches. He opened his speech with a challenge. His question was essentially, how many of the fitness professionals in the room would feel comfortable stripping down into something revealing (bathing suit or whatever) and showing our bodies to everyone.
When very few hands went up he asked, "well, what do you guys do for a living?" and as if we weren't shamed enough "why isn't every hand in this room up?". Coach Rooney was calling us out for the disconnect between what we do for a living, what we tell our clients -- and whether or not our own bodies are a reflection of that.
Given what I do for a living, clearly I value education. I honestly don't think you can be a good trainer without a whole lot of training under your belt. You can't be an idiot and be a top-notch fitness pro. But, there is also a lot to be said for someone who inspires their clients by walking their talk -- actually applying what they know and becoing a living embodiment of what they preach.
While nobody is perfect, as trainers I think we need to hold ourselves to a higher standard if we want to be respected and taken seriously.
Geralyn Coopersmith is an exercise physiologist and certified personal trainer with over 20 years of professional experience. She is the National Director of The Equinox Fitness Training Institute (EFTI) and the author of Fit and Female: The Perfect Fitness and Nutrition Game Plan for Your Unique Body Type. She has appeared on The Today Show, The Dr. Oz Show and The CBS Morning Show and she has been quoted in national magazines including: Elle, Shape, Self, Fitness, Health, More, Women's Health and many others.